I approached TheUnlikely Journal of Architecture edited by Bernie Mojzes & AC Wise with
a certain amount of anticipation—my experience with their magazine, The Unlikely Journal of Entomology, and
AC Wise's often excellent fiction, led me to believe this would at least be an
interesting experiment. TUJOE is an eclectic mix of fiction, a journal with affection for the intriguing idea, and I
expected the editors to choose with similar tendencies. In that I was not
disappointed.
The Journal opens with Go
Through by Alma Alexander—a piece which comes into the vicinity of taking
itself too seriously, but redeems the effort by flirting with the profound.
Following on its heels however, the mildly novel trappings of Three Adventures of Simon Says, The Elder
prove mere decorations on an ultimately shallow, pointless story, falling flat
on final examination. Empty characters bleed into the background of this
post-apocalyptic adventure tale set in the graveyard remains of a playground.
Next, The Painted Bones features a
shrill MC who managed to at least interest me up until the last flippant,
clichéd line, which took a topic and character with infinite opportunity for
depth and meaning, and dashed them against the rocks of tired humor.
A standard and annoying main character, whose arc is fatally
weakened by predictability and the inability to delve beyond the surface of the
presentation, ultimately hides the interesting idea and structure of The Dross Record. The ending is an
ending only in that the text stops, resolving nothing, nor inviting the reader
to draw conclusions beyond those on the page. Similarly, The Tower is about a child MC coping with tragedy, an idea unaided
by the weak prose which renders the voice childish instead of child-like. The uninspired
idea and execution adds nothing of value to this predictable and tedious entry.
On the other end of the spectrum, Geddarien by Rose Lemberg is a surreal Holocaust story about music,
the power to move past tragedy, and the ultimate deliverance of the dead into
the future by those they leave to struggle on. MC Zelig's progression from
student at his grandfather's knee to survivor is beautiful and elegantly offered
within a poignant theme often mishandled. This story is by far my favorite, followed by The Latest Incarnation of Secondhand Johnny by Mark Rigney, the issue's closing piece about dreams, empowerment and storytelling, then the lesser Go
Through. Were the rest of the issue as well-laid as this, my overall
impression would be incandescent.
In conclusion, the Unlikely Journal of Architecture shows
promise for future installments, and offers a few pieces worth investigating,
but falls short of being a completely masterful edition. Though an issue of
erratic quality, the ideas presented prove sufficient enough I am interested to
see what Unlikely does going forward. A journal supporting unusual ideas has
considerable worth.
No comments:
Post a Comment